In a death march with no plot, faceless pioneers say nothing or mumble incomprehensibly in the indie western Meek’s Cutoff. The film won a Piaget Producers Award at the Spirit Awards.
Life for three emigrant families facing almost certain death on the Oregon Trail in 1845 could make for a fascinating exploration. Instead Director Kelly Reichardt shows off in her “minimalist, radically unfashionable style” (Variety). It’s a movie that viewers will hate or love within the first five minutes.
Michelle Williams stars as Emily Tetherow. Emily and other women gather kindling. They knit. They read books. Oh, and they’re litterbugs too.
Native Americans are cursed as “no better than animals” by the group’s scout Meek (Bruce Greenwood). He is hidden under a beard, long locks and fancy, fringed buckskin. Williams sums up her feelings about him: “it’s all vanity.”
Meek and another man capture a Cayuse Indian, threaten to shoot him and chain him up like an animal each night. The menfolk demand that he lead them to water, or else surely they will die. They don’t speak his language, and he doesn’t speak theirs. He guides them anyway, to where we do not know.
Emily approaches the Indian, repulsed by his “stench” yet strangely attracted. She offers him food and stitches up his moccasin. Deadpan Emily points a rifle at Meek when he’s about to shoot the Indian. Some believe this is a feminist moment.
The Indian (Rod Rondeaux) sings over a sick man, and later speaks aloud to nature all around him. Here is a radically different worldview, a Native American's direct connection with nature. Yet these moments don’t inform or enrich. Instead the travelers stand wooden, looking catatonic. Conflict is watered down to a gruel in a wasteland of a script.
There are ways to craft characters we care about, facing death and a foreign culture terrifying to them. There are ways to forge quiet, interesting character studies. Reichardt fails to find a way. Williams, Rondeaux and Will Patton manage to register onscreen somehow.
Filmed in Burnes and Hines, Oregon, the vistas are marred by garish, streaky light. Inadequate night lighting renders faces and movements indiscernible. Sound effects cut in and out strangely. Jeff Grace’s strings screech like nails on a chalkboard.
Poor production values, pitiful acting and scant story earn an “F” for Reichardt. Known for her microbudget efforts, she directed the almost equally boring Wendy and Lucy (2008), where Williams also appears.
“Hell is full of Indians,” says Meek. No, hell is full of movies like this one.
Other films you might enjoy: True Grit; Even the Rain; Crazy Heart.
Subscribe to Secret Agent Gal Reviews.
Meek’s Cutoff 2010 / PG / 1 hour, 44 min
Cast Overview: Michelle Williams, Bruce Greenwood, Will Patton, Zoe Kazan, Paul Dano, Shirley Henderson, Neil Huff, Tommy Nelson, Rod Rondeaux
Director: Kelly Reichardt
Genre: Indie, Western, Period Piece, Drama
Recent Comments